The counting line
A pitcher card shows innings, ERA, FIP, WHIP, strikeout rate, walk rate, the gap between those two rates, home runs, and games started. Innings are the sample. A reliever with 18 innings and a starter with 110 innings do not own the same kind of ERA, even when the digits match. Games started tell you the job. A starter’s zeros and a reliever’s zeros are not interchangeable, because one of them is asked to go through a lineup more than once.
ERA is earned runs per nine innings. It includes everything the defense, the park, and the sequencing did after the ball was in play. It is the number people remember and a noisy one in the minors, where official scorers, short outings, and small parks all get a vote. WHIP is walks plus hits per inning. It tells you how crowded the bases were. It still treats a blooper and a barrel as the same hit.
Why the wins use FIP
Level Wins for a pitcher uses fielding-independent pitching, not ERA. FIP rebuilds a run average from strikeouts, walks, and home runs, which are the events the pitcher has the most say in. The formula on this site compares his FIP with the historical FIP at that level, from 1990 through 2025. A better FIP than the level, times his innings, divided by nine, becomes runs. Those runs are divided by the runs per win at the level. That is the Level Wins number on the card.
The baselines are not the same number in every league. Low-A FIP sits near 3.59. High-A near 3.74. Double-A near 3.91. Triple-A near 4.22. Rookie ball is the odd one, near 3.45, because the innings are short and the bats are young. A 3.70 FIP is a bit worse than the Low-A average, about average at High-A, and clearly better than Triple-A. Posting the FIP without the level is how a mediocre A-ball arm gets described as “major-league ready.”
Zero Level Wins is an average pitcher for that level. It is not a failed prospect. A 20-year-old at Double-A with Level Wins near zero is often the more interesting arm than a 24-year-old carving up Low-A at +2. The rank knows about age and level. The LWins column does not. Use both. The Pitchers page will sort either way, and the rank on the left will stay the rank.
Strikeouts, walks, and the job
K% and BB% are plate-appearance rates, the same idea as on a hitter card. K−BB is the gap. A pitcher can survive a modest strikeout rate if the walks are scarce and the balls in play are not flying out. He usually cannot survive a high walk rate just because the strikeouts look modern. Home runs on the card are a count, so read them next to innings. Five homers in 30 innings is a problem. Five homers in 120 is ordinary.
Starters and relievers share a card shape and should not share a workload assumption. When this site stretches a short season into a pace, a starter is scaled toward 130 innings and a reliever toward 60. The pace never shrinks a full season below what he actually did. A reliever who threw 70 innings keeps 70. A starter who threw 40 does not get to pretend the ERA of those 40 is a 180-inning major-league year. Pace is a look at the rate. It is not a prediction he will be given the ball that often.
LvlStuff+ and what it leaves out
LvlStuff+ is pitch quality, not results. One hundred is an average major-league pitch that season. Green starts at 110 and red is under 90, the same coloring as the bat score. It is shown for Triple-A and the majors only. Lower levels are not tracked here, so a Low-A arm with a dash is not a soft-tossing arm. He is an arm we do not have a stuff score for. The level under the number tells you which of the two tracked leagues the score came from. If he has both, the major-league score is the one on the board.
Location is not inside LvlStuff+. A pitcher can have a loud stuff score and a walk rate that keeps him from being usable. Read the walk rate next to it every time. Arsenal tables, where we have them, show the pitches he actually threw: velocity, how often they were in the zone, and how often they drew a swing and miss. That is description. It is not a second ranking, and it does not move Level Wins.
Major-league bWAR on a pitcher page is Baseball-Reference’s. It is not Level Wins wearing a new hat. A prospect who has already pitched in the majors keeps those innings in their own section once he is still on a farm card, and they are not added into the minor-league FIP line. When the major-league time gets long enough, about 50 innings, he leaves the prospect snapshot entirely. The minor-league seasons remain on the page so the path is still readable. If you want the free-agent arms and the big-league arms in one list, that list is MLB, sorted by last season’s bWAR, with LvlStuff+ beside it.
