The card spot is the spot
This is a reading of the 40 Man board as it stood on November 18, 2026. It will move. Promotions, published lists, and the next full season all nudge the order, and the Top 100 is the live version. What follows uses the spot on the player’s card. That spot is where the innings say he is playing, not where a scouting blurb hopes he will stick. The difference matters, and one famous name on this snapshot is the example.
Position is not a tie-breaker we mention after the fact. The ranking translation gives catchers and shortstops more defensive credit, center fielders and second basemen a smaller credit, and first basemen and designated hitters a real debit. A first baseman has to hit more than a shortstop to hold the same kind of rank. When you scan by position, you are not looking at nine equal lists. You are looking at nine different jobs.
Shortstop, second, third
Shortstop is the loudest infield spot on the board. Jesús Made, in the Milwaukee system at Double-A and still 19, sits at the top of the whole list. Leo De Vries, with the Athletics and also at Double-A at 19, and Franklin Arias, with Boston and already at Triple-A at 20, are the other shortstops in the first handful. Their Level Wins are not cartoonish. Made is near +1, De Vries near +2, Arias under +1. The rank is not claiming they are beating their leagues by four wins. It is claiming that young shortstops holding their own at those levels are the players the published lists, and the translation, both refuse to drop.
Second base is thinner. Tate Southisene, Atlanta, High-A, 19, is the clearest name whose card actually says second base. A lot of players people call “infielders” in prose are shortstops or third basemen on the card, because that is where the innings are. Third base is led, among the higher ranks, by Caleb Bonemer in the Chicago White Sox system, at Double-A at 20, with Level Wins a little over +2. If you sort the hitters by wins alone you will find louder bats. If you sort by the board you will keep Bonemer ahead of older corner bats, and that is the position adjustment doing its job.
Catcher and the corners
Catcher is where the defensive credit is largest and the offense is hardest to find. Rainiel Rodriguez, St. Louis, Double-A, 19, is the catcher this snapshot is highest on, and his Level Wins are actually loud, over +3. Ethan Salas, San Diego, has already touched Triple-A at 20 and is near average for that level rather than above it. Average at Triple-A at 20, as a catcher, is not a nothing season. Alfredo Duno in Cincinnati is the next catcher the board is keeping in the top group. Read their gloves on the player page if the innings are there. The wins will not include them.
First base has to hit. Ralphy Velazquez, Cleveland, Triple-A, 21, Josiah Hartshorn, the Cubs, High-A, 19, and Charlie Condon, Colorado, Triple-A, 23, are the names the board is willing to carry at the position. Hartshorn’s Level Wins are the loudest of the three, near +3, which is what a young first baseman needs if he is going to sit anywhere near the upper ranks. An average bat at first base is a useful minor leaguer and a hard national ranking.
The outfield cards split the same way. Center field is Walker Jenkins with Minnesota, already at Triple-A at 21, Theo Gillen with Tampa Bay at Double-A at 20, and Eduardo Quintero with the Dodgers at High-A at 20. Quintero’s Level Wins, near +4, are the kind of number that survives a sort. Jenkins and Gillen are ranked higher because the rest of the translation — age, level, the published lists — still says so. Left field is Josue De Paula, Los Angeles, Double-A, 21, near the very top of the board with Level Wins over +4. Right field is Zyhir Hope, Detroit, Double-A, 21. Both are corner bats the lists have already signed off on. The debit for a corner spot is in the math. It did not push them out.
Pitchers, and one card to read twice
The arms at the top of the board are starters. Kade Anderson and Ryan Sloan are both in the Seattle system at Double-A, 21 and 20. Anderson’s Level Wins are near +3. Sloan is closer to +1. Seth Hernandez, Pittsburgh, is at High-A at 20 and near average for the level, which is why a pure wins sort will not find him and the rank still will. Christian Zazueta, now on the Dodgers’ 40-man after they protected him, is the reminder that a rank and a roster spot are different events. The board can like him and the club can still have had to spend a spot to keep him.
Sebastian Walcott is the card to read twice. He is inside the top 10, in the Texas system, at Double-A, age 20. On this snapshot the card spot is designated hitter, because that is where the innings put him. Published lists still talk about him as a shortstop. Both can be true. The translation debits a DH. The public rank is what keeps him up. If you only read the spot, you will misfile him. If you only read the rumor, you will ignore where he actually stood. Open the player page before you repeat either sentence.
Relievers almost never lead a national prospect board, and they should not. The highest-ranked pitcher whose card says reliever rather than starter sits much further down than Anderson. That is not the site forgetting the bullpen. A one-inning arm has fewer innings, a smaller translation, and a different major-league job. Use the pitcher filter on the Rule 5 page if you want the exposed arms, and the club pages if you want one farm’s starters in order. Come back to this piece later and assume the names have moved. The positions will not.
